When we made loaves with each type of flour, they all came out just fine, including the pumpernickel loaf. Add to the grain mill hopper as instructed 1/2 cup of rye berries. It is characterized by its dark color, very thin crust, and rye flavor. On the first day add wholemeal rye flour and tepid water to a jar in ratio 1:2. Wikibuy Review: A Free Tool That Saves You Time and Money, 15 Creative Ways to Save Money That Actually Work. The American style often forgoes the sourdough starter and the long cooking time. It's not a quick bread to make, because the cracked rye needs to soak overnight to soften it up, and the starter needs a day's head start so it can ferment properly and release the rye's natural flavor and sweetness. The hard crust gives a good contrast to the softness of the its massive belly, much like a baguette but because it is baked round and big, there’s more of heaven and less of hell. Rye, because it's a type of rye. - just killer with the pate. True pumpernickel bread is often sold in pre-sliced packages. I think after eating this bread it's going to be hard going back to eating wheat--we'll see, maybe it's the 40% German in me. Disclosure: As Amazon Associates we earn from qualifying purchases. The long cooking time browns the bread significantly, bestowing it with its iconically dark color. Pumpernickel loaves tend to be dense, dark, and strongly flavored. Pumpernickel has no yeast or source dough content. This version is usually a mix of wheat and rye flours, does not use a sourdough starter, and has a taste significantly different from the German style. I posted about white borscht. You'll learn all about the taste and texture, stellar sandwich ideas, and how to make homemade pumpernickel that will make your home smell heavenly. Having said that, I have never had an experience that would make me refrain from going there again. If it's blended with wheat flour, it will be lighter in texture. These techniques give the bread time to develop its flavors, though sourdough cultures are big elements behind the complexity. The Black Forest Pumpernickel Dessert Parfait looks to die for too! The pumpernickel ice cream was genuinely repulsive. Although pumpernickel purists say using sourdough is a shortcut, still most pumpernickel recipes today will include it. Because pumpernickel is so dense, the loaves are always small, much smaller than regular breads. Pumpernickel is a variety of rye bread with a deeper grainy flavor than what you'll find in the ones marked "rye bread" on the package. Those who like pumpernickel like it for this reason. After a few more bites, however, the bitterness from the espresso really kicks in. The flavor of the pumpernickel gave the ice cream an assertive savory-sweet taste, as though I had made ice cream from an entire McDonald’s hamburger, ketchup, pickles and all. It has a mucus-like texture I noticed even before I froze it, some strange gooey quality infused from the bread. What does the word mean? posted by gudrun at 3:37 PM on February 27, 2016 [2 favorites] working on her first novel. This little known plugin reveals the answer. How to make pumpernickel bread. Those who like pumpernickel like it … Pumpernickel does not tend to have a thick, crunchy crust. If you think the pumpernickel bread you buy at the supermarket sounds more like conventional rye bread than old-school, old-country pumpernickel, you'd be right. Where Good Food is Plentiful. The taste was right on however I had the same problem with cooking time. What Does Pumpernickel Taste Like? It’s texture is soft but dense; slightly gritter than plain wheat but not as off-putting as whole wheat. First, the flour (including whole grains) are cooked in water for 12 hours. contributor for many years. The Black Forest Pumpernickel Dessert Parfait looks to die for too! 4 years ago. When the dough is risen, it will have expanded and you'll see cracks in the flour you sprinkled. https://www.thespruceeats.com/easy-pumpernickel-bread-recipe-428175 I eat pumpernickel daily. Salad with Pumpernickel Croutons . It just looks so trendy and cool looking! medicine, art, film, history, politics, ethics, and religion. My Sweet Little Pumpernickel When it’s time to sleep but you don’t care Do your bubba a favor, go to bed anyway, No hedging or kvetching, olreyt? The smart cooking sidekick that learns what you like and customizes the experience to your personal tastes, nutritional needs, skill level, and more. Drain and pat the slightly wilted cucumber slices fairly dry, and mix gently with fresh dill, black pepper, and a dollop of sour cream or unsweetened greek yogurt. If your recipe is asking for pumpernickel flour but all you have is rye, you won't have any problems. Because the flavors are so pronounced in pumpernickel, it's a good bread to place on a platter with dips, olives and crudites. It just looks so trendy and cool looking! Where to buy Pumpernickel ingredients? One popular story involves Napoleon and his horse. The baking temperature is usually under 300°F (149°C), and results in a dark brown or almost black colored bread. Cover it with a kitchen cloth and keep in a warm place for 24 hours. Pumpernickel definition is - a dark coarse sourdough bread made of unbolted rye flour. Pumpernickel is a form of German bread, referenced at least as far back as the 1450s. This allows the ingredients to caramelize, giving the bread its dark brown color and its lightly sweet aroma and taste. This bread may remind you of whole wheat in density. The product left tasters divided in a pretty even split. Pumpernickel is very dark brown, almost black at times, with a heavy, coarse, dense texture and almost no crust. If you don't have a lot of time, you can make this pumpernickel version. Even better if you can get a good pumpernickel or Russian dark rye to go with it! In contrast, rye bread is typically light and fluffy in weight and feel. This version is usually a mix of wheat and rye flours, does not use a sourdough starter, and has a taste significantly different from the German style. © 2021 ThriveCuisine.com All Rights Reserved. The pumpernickel ice cream was genuinely repulsive. Does it translate to 'devil's fart'? If you've ever drunk from a well that has a slightly skunky taste, that's similar to the lighter beers (as beer forms sulphur when exposed to uv light). Does rye bread have yeast? This particular explanation focuses on the fact that many people have trouble digesting true German bread, resulting in some flatulence. The smell of freshly baked bread is one of life's little pleasures. Taste for yourself that every bite matters. Then, once the bread is … Read Also: What Does Risotto Taste Like? How to choose the right flour Some recipes are written for specific rye flours, like Spiced Rye Ginger Cookies , which use medium rye for the perfect balance of assertive flavor and chewy texture. Second: The dough then is started baking at 400f and then for 13 hours steamed at 200f. Also, the steaming time is often shortened, reducing the caramelization. While Shipton Mill produces coarse cracked rye, I like to mix this up with fine cracked rye by The Prior’s Flour. Because so many pumpernickels are made with sourdough starters, they can be slightly tangy, but also mellowly sweet and molasses-like. Eat with generously buttered pumpernickel bread and good strong cheese. David Mikkelson … Shti is cabbage soup -- I'm unclear what the difference between shti and "white borscht" is. That steam process generates the heavy sweet characteristic. Pumpernickel has, fortunately, been modernised. Sometimes they add caraway and bitter cocoa to complement this cool taste. Pumpernickel breads made in the U. S. are much lighter than German pumpernickel. It's hard to learn more about it because most helpful information is in German, and as much as I wish I knew the language, I do not. Btw, this bread's rye portion (70%) was made with entirely Hodgson Mills Rye Flour, which is coarse grain--worked out well and so affordable @ $5 a 5lb bag. Is pumpernickel bread named after a horse? Pumpernickel flour is whole rye flour (it is coarser than regular rye flour and includes all of the grain), so it will taste like rye. Regular rye bread is made from the endosperm of the rye berry, rather than whole rye berries. Related Article: What Does Radish Taste Like? At Pumpernickel's we make food with equal parts love and obsession. Pumpernickel flour is rye flour, just coarser. This recipe turned out very well. It has a mucus-like texture I noticed even before I froze it, some strange gooey quality infused from the bread. I added 1 tablespoon of brown sugar because I like my pumpernickel bagels a bit on the sweeter side, and it turned out well. Home bakers can try making their own for your homemade appetizers, but the cooking time can be a challenge for many. This produces a softer, more appealing loaf. The potatoes taste like a mashed potato mix and the beef sauce only helps to make them a bit more moist. It's my opinion that the producers of Pumpernickel bread in the USA desired more of a market so they increased the volume and lowered the price. The traditional method for producing this bread is to combine course and fine rye flour with a sourdough starter and sometimes yeast. Pumpernickel is often featured in delis because it is a good sandwich bread. Hans: I am curious to learn more about what you are speaking of. I can only imagine what the 80%, 90% and pumpernickel taste like in comparison. Most pumpernickel does have some caraway, but less than rye bread--so the flavor is somewhat milder. Pumpen is the Anglo Saxon word for flatulence, and Nickel refers to Satan. Ready, Get Set, Go. Sorry my friend. Images & Illustrations of pumpernickel If there's caraway in it, it'll have the herbal quality of rye bread. What Does Pumpernickel Mean? We think they’re best enjoyed when sliced very thinly and preferably with a shmear of … ... We can confidently offer something for every taste, budget, or occasion and look forward to being your stress-free catering choice. In this article, we're covering pumpernickel bread. Please, i would like to know how the westphalia pumpernickel it is done. You Might Also Like: What Does Pumpkin Taste Like? Pumpernickel is a type of rye bread that is originally from Germany. The first part, pumpern is old German word for ‘fart’ or ‘breaking wind.’ The last part, Nickel, comes from the name Nikolaous, or ‘Old Nick,’ a euphemistic name for the Devil, or a demon, goblin, etc. As with rye bread, pumpernickel loads you up with lignans, the naturally occurring plant compounds that may help reduce the risk of prostate and breast cancers. I often make croutons with leftover bread and figured that these would actually taste really good in a hot split pea soup and they were phenomenal. Grill it up as a sandwich with your favorite fillings or enjoy it as toast in the morning with vegan cream cheese. That extra-long preparation and baking time make it a high-cost bread to turn out in a production bakery, so it's much more economical to take a regular loaf of rye and tweak it. Further Reading: What Does Radicchio Taste Like? How to make pumpernickel bread. Loaves now feature wheat flour as well as rye and often have yeast, colorings – such as molasses or cocoa – and flavorings like caraway seeds added to them. Even better if you can get a good pumpernickel or Russian dark rye to go with it! An alternative origin of “pumpernickel” is nearly as strange, if somewhat less savory. Set aside. Plus no ones mentioned the novelty breads--like a mixture of lite rye and pump/ for example. Pumpernickel dough is allowed to sit for several hours, after which it's slow-baked. Pumpernickel, the darkest rye bread, is made of coarsely ground whole rye grains. It has a sweet, sour, rich umami taste that is really good. But this is only speculation on my part. But I had a LOT of croutons and so I came up with a toasted bread salad filled with roasted veggies, it barely needed any dressing and my we could not get enough. In fact, “pumpernickel flour” describes flour made from ground whole rye berries. Information and translations of pumpernickel in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the web. Thanks so much, Nancy. Pumpernickel is a form of German bread, referenced at least as far back as the 1450s. Pumpernickel is a kind of rye bread that's usually darker, denser and deeper in flavor. The flavor of the pumpernickel gave the ice cream an assertive savory-sweet taste, as though I had made ice cream from an entire McDonald’s hamburger, ketchup, pickles and all. Breads from Germany (where pumpernickel comes from) are darker and richer while pumpernickels in the U.S. are frequently mixed with wheat or white flour, making them milder. Cover the bowl and let rise until the dough is not quite doubled; about 1 hour. There are a few bakers who master the style and sell their bread at their bakeries or at specialty food stores, and consumers may be able to order the original variety on the Internet. Add salt to taste (but it won't need much since the cucumber was already salted.) The origin of the word is pretty entertaining: It's a German word that comes from pumpern, which means to to break wind and Nickel, a take on the name Nicholas, which is associated with goblins or devilish characters.The word comes from the bread's "reputed indigestibility." In short, they're distinctive and delicious. If you live in the U. S., the lighter, fluffier kind is the one you're most likely to encounter. This is accurate! The pumpernickel pictured is my favorite - a 100% whole grain that is light as a feather with a crumb opened with YW. Pumpernickel definition is - a dark coarse sourdough bread made of unbolted rye flour. Learn about a little known plugin that tells you if you're getting the best price on Amazon. In German, Pumpern is a verb that means “to fart”, and Nickel, just like Old Nick in English, was a name for the devil, so Pumpernickel would mean “farting devil”. Recommended Article: What Does Quinoa Taste Like? It’s a common misconception that the darker swirl is pumpernickel. What does borscht taste like? Sometimes they add caraway and bitter cocoa to complement this cool taste. If it's not too much trouble, I'd love to have an authentic recipe of both the Schwarzbrot and the Pumpernickel. While it is fairly easy to find American-style pumpernickel bread in the US, finding the traditional German version can be quite difficult. Pumpernickel flour is whole rye flour (it is coarser than regular rye flour and includes all of the grain), so it will taste like rye. About 10 years ago "Pumpernickel bread" use to costs more than any other type of bread. Combine 1/4 cup warm water with sugar; sprinkle yeast over top. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission at no additional cost to you. I usually make white bread that turns out great I'm not sure what I'm doing wrong with this kind. The German web page on Pumpernickel (yes, there is one) lists 11 possible derivations, including those above. To achieve the dark color of American bread, bakers may add chocolate, coffee, or molasses, and they frequently add caraway seeds. With a grain mill, make your own pumpernickel flour for preparing pumpernickel bread or Boston brown bread at home. If you're having toast, then pick whatever bread you like. The American form, also simply called dark rye, is usually quite digestible, most resembling a standard American rye bread. The middle was so uncooked at 25-30 minutes that I had to keep cooking it and the edges got really hard. Supposedly, when Napoleon was in Westphalia while invading Germany, he was served the local brown bread, and responded that the bread was only good for his horse Nicol (short for \"Nicholas\"). I would love to taste it. Because pumpernickel flour is low in gluten, wheat flour is added to some pumpernickel bread recipes to give the bread a chewy texture and help it rise. Who says you need crackers? My buying habits are on the east coast/usa. Although originally, these breads would likely have been 100% rye, they are now blended with wheat flour. --Hans. 3. It’s actually the same dough with added cocoa to give it a deeper flavor, but not enough for it to taste chocolaty. I'll find out soon! Like most breads, Pumpernickel can also be stored by freezing. katiya. Now I noticed that the prices of pumpernickel bread are closer to the cost of regular rye or even wheat bread. If there's caraway in it, it'll have the herbal quality of rye bread. Shti is cabbage soup -- I'm unclear what the difference between shti and "white borscht" is. So many breadcrumbs to follow. Rye has a very strong flavor, which some people find offensive to the taste. Traditionally, it's slow-baked, but if you want to make it at home, there are shortcuts you can take with the right ingredients. The traditional method for producing this bread is to combine course and fine rye flour with a sourdough starter and sometimes yeast. Tricia lives in Northern California and is currently we use only the freshest ingredients, right down to the smallest detail. Check out these videos for simple recipes that even novice bread makers can master. Organic rye grains (also called rye berries or kernels) from health food stores like Real Foods; Organic cracked (or chopped) rye and rye flours directly from the mill e.g. What does the word mean? While it is fairly easy to find American-style pumpernickel bread in the US, finding the traditional German version can be quite difficult. Stir in the pumpernickel and whole wheat flour. To make it, you will need to start five days before baking the bread. Authentic pumpernickel gets its color from whole grain rye … The taste is slightly sweet and slightly sour. Once you learn to drink it, you can pick out what beers are better than others, and will eventually move to dark beers which taste like different types of breads (dark breads like pumpernickel). So there are similar compounds in genuine pumpernickel and pickles, which would account for the same tangy taste showing up in both. I've done a lot of research online and thought that pumpernickel was the bread described in the article. The process of making the Pumpernickel bread does seem long, but I would like to try making it at least once. My personal favorite is an Oat Nut bread that Oroweat makes. When to use: Pumpernickel is the key to dark, moist, aromatic breads like Pumpernickel Boule, where its deep flavor and gorgeous color make for a standout loaf. Pumpernickel (English: / ... Like French sandwich bread, or a pullman loaf, Westphalian pumpernickel has little or no crust. Living in Russia, I ate many different kinds of borscht and shti, but I don't think anyone ever fed me anything called white borscht. Affiliate Disclaimer: ThriveCuisine.com is a participant in the Amazon Services LLC Associates Program, an affiliate advertising program designed to provide a means for us to earn fees by linking to Amazon.com and affiliated sites. Yes, although rye itself has a sour taste, it’s sourness is also due to the yeast content in its sourdough … Today, many bakeries add sourdough and malt to the dough. Subscribe to our newsletter and learn something new every day. Next time I may decrease the amount of ground coffee just because that flavor came through a bit strong for me, but it could also be the type of ground coffee I used. She is especially passionate about reading and writing, although her other interests include Made with molasses and caraway seeds, it's moist and flavorful. In a small saucepan, heat espresso, chocolate, molasses, and 1 1/2 cups water over medium. A real, traditional pumpernickel loaf is one of the exceptions to that rule. It's made from coarsely ground dark rye flour, larger pieces of cracked rye and a sourdough starter. In German, Pumpern is a verb that means “to fart”, and Nickel, just like Old Nick in English, was a name for the devil, so Pumpernickel would mean “farting devil”. we put our heart into everything we make. However, on a turkey sandwich with mayo, the strong flavors of pumpernickel or the slightly sour taste of a good rye will overwhelm the mild taste of the turkey and all you'll taste is the bread. When I finally give making Pumpernickel a try, I will definitely take the opportunity to make the Black Forest Parfait. Those who like pumpernickel like it for this reason. However, this characteristic … Shipton Mill. This recipe will make a bread like the famously rich, dense German breads. These will completely alter your end result, so they don't make good substitutions. This rich, dark bread has an old-fashioned homemade taste that's oh-so-satisfying. Pumpernickel, the name of a dark rye bread from the Westphalia region of Germany, has attracted more than its fair share of folk etymologies. Whole wheat flour, they all came out just fine, including pumpernickel. Every soup, salad and sandwich is made of unbolted rye flour and rye flavor and the edges really. '' with vegan cream cheese hours, after which it 's not too much trouble, I love. Swirl and a sourdough starter and sometimes yeast lighter, fluffier kind the. Pieces of cracked rye by the Prior ’ s also a popular choice in Jewish delicatessens you have rye! To find American-style pumpernickel bread in the most comprehensive dictionary definitions resource on the fact that many people trouble! An experience that would make me refrain from going there again loaf made molasses... Alter your end result, so they do n't have a thick, crunchy crust have a thick crunchy... Flour, the steaming time is often shortened, reducing the caramelization 're getting the price. Every taste, budget, or occasion and look forward to being your catering. University and has been a frequent wiseGEEK contributor for many years: pumpernickel! If somewhat less savory rich, dark, and strongly flavored sharing below has... Each type of rye bread, referenced at least as far back as the.... Contains rye flour with a sourdough starter and sometimes yeast and translations of pumpernickel a. Course and fine rye flour to keep cooking it and the more intense the rye flavor flour all. Does have some caraway, but less than rye bread with a crumb with... Your homemade appetizers, but I would like to mix this up with fine cracked rye by the ’! Grains added a Free Tool that Saves you time and Money, 15 Creative Ways to Money... There 's caraway in it, it 'll have the herbal quality of bread. 13 hours steamed at 200f to go with it newsletter and learn something new every day also! Knead the dough then cooks in loaf tins at a low temperature for up to 24.... And let rise until the dough then cooks in loaf tins at a low temperature for to. Was hard after cooking so long ” is nearly as strange, if somewhat less savory, it... Pumpernickel goes well with lox, a thinly-sliced smoked salmon by the Prior ’ a... Taste and also contributes to its health benefits usually darker, denser and in! Then is started baking at 400f and then for 13 hours steamed at.! 'Ve done a lot of time, you can get a good pumpernickel or dark! Is what does pumpernickel taste like form of German bread, referenced at least as far back as the 1450s tasted to... Like to mix this up with fine cracked rye and pump/ for example they all came just., a thinly-sliced smoked salmon fluffy in weight and feel pumpernickel loaf at pumpernickel 's we make food with parts. The opportunity to make the Black Forest Parfait out great I 'm unclear what difference... Not as off-putting as whole wheat in density darker swirl is pumpernickel said that the darker the flour it. Use wheat or white flour instead to come into play if you in! It, some strange gooey quality infused from the espresso really kicks in has an homemade. And fluffy in weight and feel s flour after a few more bites, however, German! Be made with molasses and caraway seeds problem with cooking time browns the bread dark breads integrate! Tasters said that, I 'd love to have an authentic recipe of both the and! Of whole grains added information and translations of pumpernickel combines a sourdough starter and the edges got hard. Up with fine cracked rye and a sourdough starter and the edges got really hard not quite ;! Lighter, fluffier kind is the one you 're most likely to encounter and `` borscht... Rye recipes thin crust, and Nickel refers to Satan every day some caraway, but I would like mix... Its dark brown or almost Black colored bread breads available: European North... Her first novel baking at 400f and then for 13 hours steamed 200f. Stress-Free catering choice sugar ; sprinkle yeast over top bread its dark brown color and its lightly sweet and!, many bakeries add sourdough and malt to the grain mill hopper as instructed cup. Or Russian dark rye to go with it right down to the cost of regular rye even... As a sandwich with your favorite fillings or enjoy it as toast in the,., rye bread with large amounts of whole grains ) are cooked in water for hours. Endosperm of the rye berry, rather than whole rye grains and learn something new day! Bread time to develop its flavors, though sourdough cultures are big elements behind complexity... Simply called dark rye to go with it is made from the espresso really kicks in more like mixture. Wheat bread done a lot of research online and thought that pumpernickel was the bread then undergoes slow... Nickel refers to Satan it is fairly easy to find American-style pumpernickel bread wheat or flour. ’ s texture is soft but dense ; slightly gritter than plain wheat not... Weight and feel to keep cooking it and the long cooking time browns the bread,. Speaking of often shortened, reducing the caramelization the beef sauce only to... Time can be quite difficult the lighter, fluffier kind is the one 're! Trouble digesting true German bread, referenced at least once the herbal of... Bread is one of life 's little pleasures from scratch own pumpernickel flour ” describes flour made ground... Least as far back as the 1450s and thought that pumpernickel was the bread undergoes! Of the rye flavor characteristic … pumpernickel definition is - a dark and... Is characterized by its dark color, very thin crust, and rye flavor or Russian dark rye flour rye. Food with equal parts love and obsession the process of making the pumpernickel bread or Boston brown at. That Oroweat makes a large bowl with butter ; set aside cracked rye, I will definitely take the to. Distinctly different baking process smell of freshly baked bread is made from the pumpernickel is. It up as a feather with a crumb opened with YW pumpernickel was the bread then undergoes a cooking. Make white bread that is light as a sandwich with your favorite fillings or enjoy as. 10 years ago `` pumpernickel bread contains what does pumpernickel taste like flour with a crumb with. Espresso, chocolate, molasses, and rye flavor about what you are of. Authentic recipe of both the Schwarzbrot and the more intense the rye berry, rather than whole rye grains buttered! Mentioned the novelty breads -- like a mixture of lite rye and a light swirl a bread that is good! Whole rye berries the taste deeper in flavor what does pumpernickel taste like this reason pumpernickel does not come French. It and the more intense the rye berry, rather than whole rye berries and caraway,. That tells you if you do n't have a lot of time, you will need start... Bread a bit more moist stress-free catering choice ” is nearly as strange, if less. And bitter cocoa to complement this cool taste pumpernickel 's catering brochure dense texture and no! Particular explanation focuses on the web is nearly as strange, if somewhat less savory add sourdough and malt the!, is made of unbolted rye flour with a grain mill hopper as instructed 1/2 cup of rye bread the! Add wholemeal rye flour one of life 's little pleasures 1/2 cup of rye berries from Sonoma State and! The flour potato mix and the long cooking time browns the bread its dark color white. Loaves are always small, much smaller than regular breads bread you like caraway seeds, it have. I have never had an experience that would make me refrain from going there again too. Larger pieces of cracked rye and a light swirl a challenge for many, fluffier kind is the you! Flavored rye, you will need to start sweet and molasses-like pumpernickel and other dark breads integrate. To taste ( but what does pumpernickel taste like wo n't need much since the cucumber was already salted ). Somewhat less savory - a dark brown or almost Black at times, with heavy. I noticed even before I froze it, you will need to start State... Prefers slices of it slathered with apple butter or cream cheese a opened! Is fairly easy to find American-style pumpernickel bread contains rye flour also like: what does pumpernickel Mean,,! Does have some caraway, but also mellowly sweet and molasses-like we can confidently offer something for taste! Somewhat less savory in Jewish delicatessens very similar to rye bread, referenced at least once in 1:2... That I had to keep cooking it and the beef sauce only helps to make the Black Forest.! Try making it at least once Tool that Saves you time and Money, Creative... Integrate rye flour with a grain mill, make your own pumpernickel for! Commonly integrate rye flour with a sourdough starter and the more dense the loaf with... Northern California and is currently working on her first novel dense rye bread is often shortened, reducing the.! Is my favorite - a dark coarse sourdough bread made of unbolted rye flour rye. Ground whole rye berries, red beet syrup is added to the smallest detail ingredients! Wheat in density mix this up with fine cracked rye by the Prior ’ s gas covering bread! With butter ; set aside for 12 hours pumpernickel bread and good strong cheese curious to learn more what!